Look at some of these characters: Jason White, Eric Crouch, Troy Smith (sadly) and of course Johnny (Football?) Manziel. Of course their are a few exceptions like Eddie George. They need to expand their field and look at all players on the team:
Such as 1996: Danny Wuerffel versus Orlando Pace. – Not such a hard choice in hindsight. Pace was the most dominant player on the field that year – no question.